Alan Osmond Of The Osmond Family Pens Anti-Gay Article Defending Gay Reparative Therapy and the Mormon Church

Will Kohler

Will Kohler is a noted LGBT historian, writer, blogger and owner of Back2Stonewall.com. A longtime gay activist, Will fought on the front lines of the AIDS epidemic with ACT-UP and continues fighting today for LGBT acceptance and full equality. Will’s work has been referenced in notable media venues as MSNBC and BBC News, The Washington Post, The Advocate, The Daily Beast, Hollywood Reporter, Raw Story, and The Huffington Post

You may also like...

19 Responses

  1. Chicago Bob says:

    Two comments. His niece (Marie’s daughter) is a lesbian. Wonder how she feels. And this article will hopefully be more fuel against Willard Romney when he gets the nomination for the repub presidential race.

  2. Oh good grief. An ugly website, and when I look at what he writes, it’s clear he is also an ugly, smallminded person.

    Even more scary: he promotes quack medicine (salt water can cure everything except smallminded viciousness, it would seem).

  3. Jeff says:

    Interesting article. What’s more interesting, though, is that the headline isn’t supported by the content. I couldn’t care less about the Osmonds or what they think, but neither do I see anything in the quoted passage that qualifies as “anti-gay,” much less anything inaccurate.

    “Many researchers whose studies have been used to support a biological model for homosexuality [really] have determined that their work has been misinterpreted.” It doesn’t matter what your opinion of homosexuality be; the facts remain that some studies have been used (for good and bad) in ways that the original researchers never intended, much less support.

    “Homosexuality results from an interaction of social, biological, and psychological factors. These factors may include temperament, personality traits, sexual abuse, familial factors, and treatment by one’s peers.” Again, dead on. I’m not sure how anyone could argue differently. These factors appear in differing proportions for person to person, and it’s wholly possible that some factors might not be active in a particular individual at all. But the statement, as worded, is completely accurate.

    “Developmental factors aside, can individuals diminish homosexual attraction and make changes in their lives? Yes. There is substantial evidence, both historical and current, to indicate this is the case.” Again, dead on. As the cited quote explains, there really are people that have overcome their same-sex attraction and lived long and fulfilling lives. Sure, some haven’t. Some have even become depressed enough to take their own lives, which is horrible. But the fact of the matter is that while there is no one-size-fits-all solution to same-sex attraction, there are plenty of people that have successfully “bridle[d] all [their] passions” (to use the common phrase), just like there are people that have successfully overcome all sorts of aberrant behaviors.

    I think there are two main problems here: first, that people tend to toss around the word “homophobia” to describe any belief that doesn’t include the complete and wholesale acceptance of homosexuality as a fully appropriate lifestyle choice; and second, that people are genuinely afraid of differing beliefs, as evidenced by the extreme homophobophobia expressed in this article.

    Sorry, guys. Bad show.

    • Will Kohler says:

      Bad show right back at ya.

      Just because you say its so doesn’t make it true.

      Everything from the 50% success rate to being gay having to do with social developement is misinformation according to the AMA and APA.

      So therefore it is anti-gay and also propaganda to boot.

    • Roy McKenzie says:

      You don’t see supporting ex-gay therapy as being homophobic?

      Just another Mormon Jesus freak thumping your bible beliefs around. After reading one of your blogs on your site (wish I could take back that page view) I can see you’ve rationalized your homophobia as well.

      “Does it mean that we should legalize homorrhage? Heck no, for the same reason that we shouldn’t legalize murder. “I was born that way” does not constitute a valid defense for decriminalizing harmful behavior. (As an aside, homosexuals can get married and have that marriage recognized by the Church; they just can’t homorry and have it recognized. But I digress.)”

      Fuck off Jeff. Really, just fuck off.

    • Joe G says:

      Anti-gay comments from this Osmond fellow:

      “First, it is important to understand that homosexuality is not innate and unchangeable.”

      “Developmental factors aside, can individuals diminish homosexual attraction and make changes in their lives? Yes.”

      Then there’s his whole support of “reparative therapy”, which itself is just an offensive term since there is absolutely nothing to repair.

      Then your amazingly insightful comment:

      “I think there are two main problems here: first, that people tend to toss around the word “homophobia” to describe any belief that doesn’t include the complete and wholesale acceptance of homosexuality as a fully appropriate lifestyle choice;”

      First of all, stop using the word homosexual, homosexuality, etc. It is a very clinical and outdated term. The proper terms are “gay”, “being gay”, etc.

      Second, being gay is not a lifestyle choice. A lifestyle choice is whether to get married, whether to have kids, whether to move for a job, whether to continue education, whether to be a douchebag, etc. Being gay is part of your identity and has nothing to do with a lifestyle choice. Your sexual identity is immutable.

      Third, yes, if you do not fully accept gay people for who they are, then that is homophobia.

    • Allen Miller says:

      It’s obvious that Jeff is as misinformed about the origins of homosexuality as our good friend Alan Osmond. The latest research supports the theory that homosexuality has genetic origins with an in utero chemical trigger. Temperament, personality traits, sexual abuse, familial factors, and treatment by one’s peers are not causal, but are all factors impacted by innate homosexuality.

      At best, reparative therapy DIMINISHES homosexual desires in men who score 3-4 on the Kinsey Scale, men who would be considered bisexual rather than homosexual. It should be noted that it does not eliminate these desires. Over time, homosexual urges tend to re-emerge. Any benefit is at best temporary and can best be ascribed to suppression rather than actual cure.

      What bothers me most about Osmond’s comments is that they continue to reinforce an out-dated stereotype that one is gay by choice and can become straight by “praying the gay away.” This false message results in a culture within the LDS Church that fosters misunderstanding at best and bigotry and hate at worst.

      • steve says:

        One thing I agree with in Jeff’s post is, do not throw the term homophobia or homophobe around indescriminately. The overuse will diminish it’s sting. Remember the OJ trial and the racial card ? Also I think that, at least some gays are reperable. You have to figure that in all the gays in the US, some of them might respond to therapy. I myself would not. I have craved male bubble butts since before I knew what sex was, as in second grade. So I think I was “born this way”. But as a community don’t be so arogant as to think that we know all the answers to gayness and its causes. It definately is not a choice. Why would I choose a life where my strong urges have to be masked and restrained as opposed to one where I can openly hug and kiss my sweetheart. I wouldn’t, and I believe that we are placed in this orientation because GOD wanted it that way. Why, no idea, I am not as smart as he is.

  4. He should read this:

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/8878301/Rugby-player-who-had-stroke-woke-up-gay-and-became-hairdresser.html

    For me, this nails the lid shut on the Nature/Nurture debate. Homosexuality is wired into people. This guy had an accident that rewired him, so now is he is a homosexual. It could work the other way, if for example I had a stroke or an accident – I might end up heterosexual. The sheer vastness of the numbers of homosexuals on the planet, and the irreversibility of their orientation despite all they’re put through is gradually dawning on people as our confidence grows with the floodgates of empancipation now inching open.

  5. Electroshock aversion therapy and the administration of nausia-producing drugs to males at Brigham Young University was a total failure. One must assume that these individuals were highly motivated to change (for reasons to complex to discuss in detail here). If administering electric shocks to the genitalia of highly motivated men was ineffective, what are the chances that a group hug form of therapy will be effective? Like so many others of his ilk, Alan Osmond is living in a fantasy world.

  6. Normie says:

    I have a cure for it…get straight people to stop producing the little buggers…lol If all the people of the world were straight, this poor old world would have over populated long ago. I love the Osmonds but Alan is by far not educated enough to understand the different types of human nature. Why don’t people like him try and stop people who rape, kill, murder women and children. They hardly ever mention these deviants in the world but someone gay, and cripes the shit hits the fan. Being gay isn’t about sex.

  7. Michael Reed says:

    Marie has a daughter who is GAY…wonder how she feels about this stuff…would like her to make a statment!!

  8. Lori says:

    People….we are here to do God’s will! His will is sacred..! We are NOT here to do whatever we want free for all! God said, NO and he meant it! He created marriage read the Bible it was not Adam and Steve or Eve and Betty! It was Adam and Eve!!! You can change all the rules and laws in the world you want to….the answer on being Gay from God is NO!!! End deal…he has spoken! Respect it!! Because if you don’t…his laws are very serious if broken! Stop thinking everything is about us humans! There is a greater plan at hand…..get it right! What part of NO don’t liberals on gay understand???? Toying with God is just WOW arrogant and bratish….God give me my way or else….God say’s….Obey my commandments…he was no kidding!.

  1. November 10, 2011

    […] anti-gay ramblings, posted on a Osmond Family owned website,  were discovered by Back2Stonewall blogger Will Kohler who writes,”In his article, which is so misinformed, ill written and LDS cultlike you expect […]

  2. November 10, 2011

    […] Alan Osmond, the eldest of the singing group The Osmonds, says being gay is not genetic, reparative therapy is successful, and by this picture you can tell that he is so NOT gay! Full story here! […]

  3. November 10, 2011

    […] story was unearthed in October by writer Will Kohler for the LGBT blog Back2Stonewall. Kohler called the article “so misinformed, ill written and LDS cultlike you expect kool-aid to be served alongside of […]

  4. November 11, 2011

    […] Back2Stonewall, What do you think of this post?LOL (0) WTF (0) Hot (0) More Please (0) […]

  5. December 14, 2013

    […] the past few years I have been reporting on and off  about Alan Osmond, best known for his years as one of the Osmond Family singers. (The one with the z~mutton […]

What do you think?